Celebrating Halloween: A Question of Identity, Not Just a Festival
By Sana Shoaib
Why do we want to belong to something that was never ours nor meant to be?
In the last week of October 2026, various commercial centres and shopping plazas were loaded with orange pumpkins, black balloons, witches, ghosts with scary sale boards everywhere, endorsing it as our culture. Malls don’t decorate for fun; they decorate for business; they know what will sell.
One is bound to think: when did a night about ghosts and darkness become our celebration? And more importantly: why? This change didn’t just come overnight; three quiet changes brought it to us.
Today, a festival does not need to be believed to be celebrated. It only needs to be posted. When every reel is about a Halloween costume, when every story is a ‘spooky night’, a child feels left out, and naturally no child needs to be left out. It is not about shirk or belief for them, it is about belonging.
It’s a grim reality that FOMO – the fear of missing out – is getting stronger than our connection to our own identity. The children are not following a festival; they’re following a feed.
Halloween did not come to us through a textbook. It came packaged as ‘fun’ and ‘modern’ – through few private schools and colleges, some exclusive gatherings, and now shopping centres. A Halloween party apparently feels harmless; a costume competition feels like creativity. And to say ‘no’ to it labels being backward, strict, or old-fashioned.
This is very dangerous. The next generation has started believing that to be modern, we must borrow someone else’s celebrations. As if our own Deen is not modern enough; our own culture is not colourful enough.
This is the hardest truth: many of us have forgotten the joy of our own festivals. When our own celebrations become dry and formal, our children will look elsewhere for excitement. A child who does not feel the enthusiasm of Layla Tul Jaiza, the joy of Eid and even Eid Milan, the peace of a night spent in dua, would most probably feel thrilled by costumes and makeups, even if it’s about ghosts and fear.
Understanding Halloween
Let us try to understand it simply, without fear. Halloween comes from an old festival called Samhain. People believed that on that night, the spirits of the dead returned. To protect themselves, they wore scary costumes and lit fires. Later, it became a festival of horror: ghosts, witches, skeletons, blood, death.
We are Muslims; believe in Tawheed. We believe in the unseen, but we do not venerate fear. We believe life is an amanah from Allah, and death is not complete end or total annihilation, rather it’s a natural and predetermined transition of the soul from the temporary physical world (Dunya) back to Allah.
Does a Muslim, who believes in the light of Allah, really need a festival that celebrates darkness, fear and death? We do not need to abhor anyone else’s festival, but we do need to ask: is this ours? This is where the real question begins. The important question is not, ‘Can we wear a costume?’ The authentic question is, ‘Whose approval are we seeking?’
Have the Muslims started celebrating it because they are afraid of being left out? Or because they want to look modern? Or because it gives joy? Our Prophet ﷺ said: “Whoever imitates a people is one of them.” (Sunan Abi Dawud: 4031) This hadith is not about animosity; it is about responsibility of identity. It is reminding us: if you keep borrowing someone else’s way of celebrating, someone else’s way of living, someone else’s way of thinking, then where is your identity? Identity is not a costume one wears for one night; identity is what you carry inside every day. The confusion is about imitation. We pray, but we also copy. We talk about Islam, but we also run after every ‘modern’ trend.
We don’t need a night to pretend to be ghosts, when Allah has already given us a night, Laylatul Qadr, that is better than a thousand nights. We are not lacking festivals; we are lacking connection to them. We have Ramadan full of light, we have nights of dua that can change our qadr. We have Eids full of joy. We have stories of Prophets that are far more powerful and gripping than any story.
So what is our responsibility as parents and teachers? It’s to make our own celebrations so alive, so joyful, full of love, that our children never feel the need to borrow someone else’s darkness to feel happy. Because a child who has tasted the light of his/her own Deen will never run after someone else’s darkness.
About the author: The writer is a published author, former teacher and a freelance contributor. She writes on faith, resilience, and finding meaning in everyday struggle.
tanzeemdigitallibrary.com © 2026